Seagate NAS Vs WD Red - Best NAS Drives

Seagate NAS HDD Vs WD Red - Best NAS Hard Drives

When it comes NAS boxes, Seagate NAS HDD or WD Red hard drives are what you need to protect your files.

Network Attached Storage boxes have a special requirement when it comes to data storage. Unlike desktop PCs, where high RPM drives for fast file access or games are popular. The demands of a NAS enclosure is actually quite different. 24/7 reliability is much more important than fast file access.

Unlike 7200 and even 10,000 RPM hard drives typically found in a desktop computers. Video streaming can easily be accommodated by slower 5400 RPM drives. Tivo and other DVR manufacturer's have been using these slower drives successfully for video recording for many years.

NAS boxes require hard drives especially built for reliability, and continuous use. Sure, you can load up a NAS enclosure with a mismatched collection of used hard drives you may have laying around. If a drive fails and you end up losing your lifetime media or photo collection, you will end up wishing you didn't.

While both Seagate and Western Digital make a wide range of hard drives including Solid State Drives (SSD) which are perfect for the NAS operating system. They also make a line of hard drives built especially for NAS data storage. While you certainly can outfit your NAS box entirely with higher capacity SSD drives, the cost to do this is still very expensive. Old school spinning platter hard drives are still the best choice for a NAS or Server since they offer much higher data capacity at an affordable price.

Seagate NAS HDD

Seagate NAS HDD vs Western Digital Red Hard Drives

Seagate and Western Digital are the big players in the industry when it comes to hard drives. They are both long established companies that have been around for many years now. Seagate has released their own special NAS HDD hard drive line which was designed especially for servers and the network attached storage market.

Their hard drives are available in three sizes 2, 3 and 4TB which can meet the needs of small business owners or ever growing home media libraries.

Seagate NAS HDD drives have an incredible 1 million hours of Mean Time Between Failure (MTBF). Their drives also come with a 3 year warranty for extended peace of mind knowing that  they believe in their product enough to stand behind it.

Seagate NAS HDD drives are still relatively new compared to the WD Red line of hard drives which have been out for a long while now. While they do not have the same number of reviews. These drives do have a very high rating and are equally liked by people that choose to use them over the WD Red drives.

Helpful Tips For Choosing NAS Drives

  • USE SAME HARD DRIVES: When selecting drives for your NAS, it's important to choose drives of the same size and model. This ensures that your RAID will function properly. While you can mismatch different size drives of the same make and model.  Your RAID redundant backup will only be as large as your smallest drive. You will only be wasting money unless you plan on upgrading all your drives to a larger size at a later time.

  • UDATE DRIVE FIRMWARE: Hard drives like many other electronic devices often benefit by updating to the latest firmware version. We will provide links at the end of this article to locate and download the necessary files to update both the Seagate NAS HDD and WD Red hard drives to the latest version. These firmware updates can provide bug fixes, or even enhance hard drive performance.

  • COST: On the smaller hard drives both Seagate and WD Red are priced very closely. It's only when you get to the 6TB drives that the WD Red offers a significant price advantage. This may not matter much if you only have a dual drive NAS. When you need 8 drives or more, the cost savings can really start adding up.

Western Digital Red

WD Red NAS Drives have been out for a while now and are extremely popular. Built and designed to offer a long 24/7 service life in a tough server or NAS environment. 

They have a huge base of loyal customers and have built a favorable reputation for building quality hard drives over the years.

The WD Red line of hard drives are now available in many sizes in 1TB increments from 1 to 6TB. They also come with a 3 year warranty to offer extended peace of mind that your data will be kept safe and secure.

Seagate NAS vs WD Red - Video Review

Bottom Line

Compared head to head, there really is no significant difference or advantage in performance between these two drives.

Since both Seagate NAS HDD and WD Red Drives are optimized for a RAID Array in a NAS or server environment, we recommend choosing the drive that offers the best price. Choose the brand you feel the most loyal to. You simply can't go wrong with either one of these hard drives.

Additional Information and Resources:

WD Red

  • View the Complete Line of WD Red Hard Drives on Amazon »
  • Get Manuals and Latest Firmware Updates for WD Red Drives »

  • Seagate NAS HD

  • View the Complete Line of Seagate NAS HDD Drives on Amazon »
  • Get Manuals and Latest Firmware Updates for Seagate NAS HDD Drives »

  • You may also enjoy reading: